Peer Review
Peer Review Process
1. Manuscripts (national and international articles, interviews, and reviews) submitted to the journal *Lumina* undergo a scientific review process—a double-blind peer review—conducted by two experts in the field, appointed by the Editorial Board.
2. The Editorial Team reserves the right to decline the publication of manuscripts that: do not align with the journal’s scope (based on a preliminary assessment by the scientific editors); exhibit a high degree of similarity to other works (verified via anti-plagiarism software, as detailed in the Author Guidelines); fail to adhere to scientific writing standards or ABNT (Brazilian National Standards Organization) requirements (a template is provided); do not comply with the guidelines and regulatory standards for research involving human subjects (Resolution No. 466/12) or the standards applicable to research in the Humanities and Social Sciences (Resolution No. 510/16); or receive unfavorable evaluations during the double-blind peer review process.
3. Lumina ensures the anonymity of authors throughout the article review process.
4. Regarding the review process and criteria: each manuscript is evaluated anonymously by two reviewers whose research area and/or professional expertise are relevant to the content of the submission. The evaluation form covers criteria for scientific quality across the following categories: the relevance of the topic to the field of Communication; alignment with the journal’s scope; clear articulation of objectives and whether they are effectively achieved; the currency and appropriateness of the references used; the consistency of the theoretical framework; the clear description, suitability, and application of the methodology and procedures employed; the clarity, fluency, coherence, and grammatical accuracy of the text; adherence to the formal conventions of scientific writing; the suitability of the title; the adequacy of the abstract (i.e., whether it describes the objectives, theoretical framework, methods used, and key results); and an overall assessment of the research's social impact.
5. Following the assessment of these categories, each reviewer indicates whether the manuscript is "Approved," "Rejected," or requires "Mandatory Revisions." It should be noted that a manuscript for which reviewers have requested "Mandatory Revisions" is not considered "Accepted." Finally, in a designated text field, the reviewer must provide comments regarding their overall assessment, including clear instructions on the changes required (in cases of approval pending revision) or the reasons for rejection. These comments are used to provide feedback to the author(s).
6. Editorial decisions regarding each manuscript are made based on the reviewers' evaluations. In cases where there are two "Approved" or two "Rejected" reviews, the author(s) are immediately notified of the editorial decision (which entails receiving the reviews and the corresponding acceptance or rejection notice). If one review is "Approved" and the other is "Approved with revisions," the reviews (with identifying information removed) are sent to the author, who is then asked to submit a revised version of the manuscript; this new version is assigned to two *Lumina* journal editors for a decision. In the event of conflicting reviews—one "Approved" and one "Rejected"—a third reviewer is appointed. If this third review is "Rejected" or "Approved with revisions," the author is immediately notified of the editorial decision (rejection, with the manuscript archived in the system). If the third review is "Approved," all three reviews are sent to the author(s), along with a request for a revised version. In cases where both reviews are "Approved with revisions," the editors assess whether the required changes are substantial. If the changes are fundamental (e.g., issues with the scope, methodology, or theoretical framework), the editorial decision is to reject the manuscript, and it is archived in the system. If the changes are more straightforward (e.g., copyediting, requests for clarification on secondary points, etc.), the author is asked to submit a revised version. The final decision regarding acceptance and publication always rests with the journal’s editorial team.
7. Within the system, reviewers may submit supplementary documents for the editorial team. As a final step, editors are asked to provide a specific editorial decision (Accept, Mandatory Revisions, Resubmit to the journal, Submit to another journal, Reject, or See Comments).
8. Some published manuscripts may originate from invitations extended by *Lumina* to experts in the field; in such cases, these submissions are still subject to the standard evaluation procedures. and editing handled by the editors.
